Meeting of the Advisory Council of non-profit partnership "Union of Appraisers Republic of the Republic of Tatarstan"

At the request of the Ministry of Land and Property of the Republic of Tatarstan, experts of the Union of Appraisers of Tatarstan held a peer-reviewed and accepted a professional opinion on a number of reports on the market value of real estate (including land), which is municipal property in Bavlinsky and Aksubayevsky Districts.

Experts Andrey Lisichkin Dmitry Zahmatov, Damir Timershin, Alsou Gilyazova, Marat Suleymanov, which are the members of the management and control bodies of basic SRO’s of Russia, the working bodies of the Council on the evaluation of activities of the Ministry of Economic Development of Russia, conducted a preliminary analysis and review reports and heard the views of the staff of appraisal department of the Ministry of land and property of the Republic of Tatarstan and appraisers. The ministry, and experts pointed out in many areas of the republic repeatedly poor-quality level of performance appraisal works, paid from local budgets, the lack of primary control by the authorities of municipalities over the reliability of the results presented, compliance with market counterparts and valuation standards. As a result - the market value of the property on the documents submitted understated from 6.5 to 28 times. And if for objects in Aksubaevsky municipal district, appraisers, and the head of CLP of Aksubaevsky municipal district taken a constructive approach in the dialogue with experts, officers of the appraisal department of the Ministry of land and property of the Republic of Tatarstan built a scheme for further cooperation to enhance the quality of evaluation, so about the appraisal organization of the Bavlinsky municipal district adopted a recommendation in the form of professional opinion handling customer self-regulatory organization and Rosreestr, taking into account the repeated unfulfillment by appraiser of substandard work and lack of response to the comments. Under current legislation, three disciplinary penalties of SRO automatically imply a ban to engage in valuation activity.

Members of the Expert Advisory Board and employees of the Ministry of land and property of the Republic of Tatarstan noted as a positive factor the objective consideration of controversial issues involved and clarify by the head of the Chamber of Land and Property of Aksubayevsky District Svetlana Krainova and recommended that in future, involve the consideration of representatives of municipalities.